Balsam fir trees across state are dying, spring weather likely to blame, DNR says

From Wisconsin DNR Forestry News:

In early June we started getting reports of balsam fir trees rapidly changing from green to rusty red and dying in just a matter of weeks. Reports and observations are still coming in at the time of this writing, so this article gives a brief synopsis of what we’ve seen so far this year. Symptoms have been observed in some northern and central counties.

The pattern of mortality on these trees seems to match what we saw in the spring of 2018. An article summarizing the 2018 event can be found starting on page 28 of our 2018 Forest Health Annual Report. Like in 2018, no insect or disease issues have been identified that could have caused this mortality, leading us to suspect that spring weather events are once again to blame.

Symptoms appear to be the same as we saw in 2018:

• All sizes of balsam fir can be affected, from seedlings and saplings up to large trees
• The top half or two-thirds of the crown, or even the whole tree, dies quickly, typically within a month
• Trees in any location can be affected, including those in the understory and those that are found in open conditions, forests, plantations and yards.
• Some impacted trees may be found right next to trees that don’t appear to be impacted at all.
• No insect or disease pests appear to be the main cause of mortality although bark beetles and armillaria root disease were noted in a small number of the affected trees.
• Margins between dead tops and live bottoms of trees were not defined by canker margins, indicating that this mortality is not caused by a fungal pathogen.
  
  
• Counties in blue have had reports of rapid mortality of balsam fir this spring. Map is current as of July 1, 2020.

The symptoms we are seeing are not the same as normal winter burn or winter desiccation, which can impact conifers by drying out some needles. The winter of 2019-2020 was relatively mild with many winter ice/lake events cancelled due to poor ice conditions. We had many warm days in January, but we also had a few bitterly cold days and nights in March and April. On April 15 there were extremely cold temperatures around the state, and just two weeks later temperatures soared into the 60’s and 70’s accompanied by a number of days with very low relative humidity levels. Could one of these weather events have prompted this mortality event?